Top Colleges Seeking Diversity From A New Source: Transfer Students

Dec 4, 2018
Originally published on December 6, 2018 4:44 am

When applying to many of the nation's top universities, if you aren't accepted in that first, extremely competitive, round of admissions, you're not likely to get in. But some institutions are trying to change that.

This fall semester, Princeton University offered admission to 13 transfer students, the first transfer admissions in nearly three decades. In reinstating the school's transfer program, they wanted to encourage applicants from low-income families, the military and from community colleges.

It's a part of the wave of attempts by elite schools to diversify their campuses. Just 3 percent of enrollment at these top colleges are students from low-income students. And a proven ground for recruiting smart, low-income students is through transfers, especially from community colleges.

"They're bringing perspectives out of their experience that would otherwise be lacking here," says Keith Shaw, the director of Princeton's transfer, veteran and non-traditional student programs. Of the 13 students offered admission this fall, nine accepted. They include military veterans, young families and older students.

"It's not like you admit nine students, and it's suddenly wildly changed the campus culture," Shaw explains. But, he says, having those students on campus, "goes a long way towards changing the campus culture and making it a little bit more reflective of the broader American public that it's drawing on."

Private colleges across the county have embraced this method: Amherst College in Massachusetts hosts job fairs and open houses for community college students; the University of Southern California has one of the largest transfer programs among elite schools, with about 1,500 students getting slots each year. In Minnesota, several of the state's private colleges have transfer agreements with local community colleges, and similar agreements are happening across the country.

"Diverse students are the fastest growing demographic in the U.S.," says Heather Durosko from the National Association for College Admission Counseling. "It's really important for our colleges recognizing that trend to realize that more and more of their students are going to be coming from that pathway."

Here's a look at the numbers:

  • Community colleges enroll 41 percent of all U.S. undergraduates.
  • 56 percent of Native American undergrads are enrolled in community colleges.
  • 52 percent of Hispanic undergrads are enrolled in community colleges.
  • 43 percent of African American undergrads are enrolled in community colleges.

And admissions offices are paying attention: 9 in 10 regard transfer students as considerably or moderately important to overall enrollment goals, according to NACAC's "State of College Admission" report. And 64 percent of admissions directors indicated that their college will make greater efforts to recruit transfer students, according to a survey of admissions directors by Inside Higher Ed.

Private colleges are also hiring admissions officers dedicated exclusively to transfers and community college students. At Amherst, that person is Lexi Hurd. Every November, the top New England college hosts an open house for prospective community college students.

"I'm glad you're all here," she told the students who attended the event this fall, "it's a risk to even come here and think about a place like Amherst in your educational journey."

She answered lots of questions about the admissions process — and gave advice about how to make the application work for an older student bringing different experiences than the traditional 18-year-old applying straight from high school.

"If you're working, please put that in [the application], if you have family responsibilities, please put that it there. "

The small size of the study body came up several times — Amherst typically only offers transfer spots to a few dozen students. And that's true for many of the elite schools: In addition to having smaller enrollments than most public institutions, in general, transfer spots are often very limited. Many of these top schools also have access to endowments that help cover tuition for transfer students — another important factor, as many students choose community college because of finances.

Maria Aybar, now a junior at Amherst, counts herself among the lucky few. She came to the U.S. with her mother from the Dominican Republic when she was a teenager. In high school, her English wasn't that great — and when it came time for college, she was a bit lost.

"The SAT's, why do I have to take them?" she recalls thinking, "How do you apply for colleges? Why there are so many colleges in this country? There are so many things that you just don't know."

So, like a lot of her peers, she enrolled at a community college. There, she improved her writing, took honors classes and worked towards an associates degree. Three and a half years later — she transferred to Amherst.

"I never thought I would go to an elite school, as they call them," she says, laughing.

But looking back, getting in was the easy part. Right before Maria Aybar started classes, her mom lost her job.

"It was hard for me to be here and have food on my plate when I wasn't sure how my mom was doing," she remembers. Her mom eventually found work, but then the heavy course load took over, amid the constant self-doubts of, "am I really good enough to be here?"

"Here, students they talk a certain way," Aybar explains. "They have these huge words they constantly use in class and they're able to make these amazing connections. You think: 'I can't do that.' But it's actually not that you can't do it, it's that you have not been prepared for that."

Support for transfer students once they enroll is key, explains Princeton's Keith Shaw. On the elite New Jersey campus, the transfer program is just one part of a broader suite of initiatives, he says. And students who enroll as transfer students have summer programs to help them get them ready for life in the Ivy League, including math and science introductions to ready them for the rigorous coursework and volume.

At Amherst, things eventually got better for Maria Aybar. She says all the resources available on campus helped.

I asked her: When you were in high school, would you have believed all this? That you're now a junior at Amherst? She shakes her head and starts to tear up.

"When you have big dreams and you don't have the resources for it, you feel trapped and you feel that nothing is ever going to change," she says, "so being able to be here and to fulfill my dream of education means the world to me."

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

AILSA CHANG, HOST:

At some of our nation's top universities, more and more students are coming from an unlikely place - community college. That's because many Ivy League and other elite schools are accepting more transfer students. This is unusual because for the longest time at elite schools, if you didn't get in as a freshman, you didn't get in at all. NPR's Elissa Nadworny explains what's behind this change.

ELISSA NADWORNY, BYLINE: Walk across the green at Amherst College, a top liberal arts school in Massachusetts, and you'll most likely see a campus full of 18 and 19-year-olds. But more and more, you meet people like this.

MARIA AYBAR: My name is Maria Aybar. I'm a transfer student. I transferred September 2017. I never really thought that I was going to go to an elite school, as they call them.

NADWORNY: Maria and her mother came to the U.S. from the Dominican Republic when she was a teenager. Her English wasn't that great. And when it came time for college, she was a bit lost.

AYBAR: The SATs, why do I have to take them? How do you apply for colleges? (Laughter) Why are there are so many colleges in this country? Like, there were so many things that you just don't know.

NADWORNY: So like a lot of her peers, she enrolled at community college. There, she improved her writing. She took honors classes and worked towards an associate's degree. Three and a half years later, she transferred to Amherst. More and more elite private schools are trying to diversify their student bodies by recruiting students like Maria. Just this year, Princeton University enrolled its first group of transfer students in nearly three decades, and many are from community college. It's part of an attempt to make elite colleges look like the rest of America.

HEATHER DUROSKO: Diverse students are the fastest-growing demographics in the U.S.

NADWORNY: That's Heather Durosko from the National Association of College Admission Counseling.

DUROSKO: So it's really important for colleges recognizing that trend to realize that more and more of their students are going to be coming from that pathway.

NADWORNY: Indeed, more than half of Hispanic undergrads are enrolled at community colleges. The same is true for Native Americans, and about 40 percent of African-American students go to community college. And schools are recognizing that, hiring admissions officers dedicated exclusively to transfer and community college students. At Amherst, that person is Lexi Hurd.

LEXI HURD: There's a lot of high-achieving students who end up at two-year schools.

NADWORNY: Finances have a lot to do with it, but there are other factors.

HURD: They feel like, maybe I have a lot of pressure to stay near home. Or, no one in my family's gone to college before, so let me dip my toes in this for a little bit and then potentially sort of expand my wings.

NADWORNY: And expanding those wings, Lexi Hurd knows that that can be scary and confusing.

HURD: Their learning curve in that first semester is a steep one. And I think that that's a really important message for people to know (laughter).

NADWORNY: So it's not just recruiting from community colleges, she says. There has to be support when those students actually enroll because things like this happen. Right before Maria Aybar started at Amherst, her mom lost her job.

AYBAR: It was hard for me to be here and have food in my plate while I wasn't sure how my mom was doing.

NADWORNY: It was a hit on her confidence on top of the heavy course load and the constant doubts of, am I really good enough to be here?

AYBAR: Here, students, they talk a certain way. You know, they have these huge words that they constantly use in class. And they're able to make these amazing connections and things like that. And times you feel like, oh, my God, I can't do that. You know? Like - and it's not like you can't do it. It's just that you have not been yet prepared for that.

NADWORNY: After that first semester, things got better for Maria. There is a transfer students center on campus and lots of resources. When she thinks back to her time in high school and then community college, she can hardly believe that she's now a junior at Amherst.

AYBAR: When you have big dreams, and you don't have the resources for it, you feel trapped. And you feel that nothing is ever going to change. So being able to be here and to fulfill my dream of education means the world to me.

NADWORNY: She says she's starting to see that her professors and her classmates value that she brings a different perspective. And all those big, fancy words, they can't take that away. Elissa Nadworny, NPR News, Amherst, Mass. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.