Scientists have invented a device that can quickly produce large numbers of living entities that resemble very primitive human embryos.
Researchers welcomed the development, described Wednesday in the journal Nature, as an important advance for studying the earliest days of human embryonic development. But it also raises questions about where to draw the line in manufacturing "synthetic" human life.
Other scientists have previously created synthetic embryos, which are also known as embryoids. These entities are made by coaxing human stem cells to form structures found in very early human embryos. The research has raised questions about how similar to complete embryos they could and should be allowed to become.
The new work takes such research further by creating a method that can rapidly generate relatively large numbers of embryoids.
"This new system allows us to achieve a superior efficiency to generate these human embryo-like structures," says Jianping Fu, an associate professor of biomedical engineering at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, who led the research.
Fu calls the step "an exciting new milestone for this emerging field" that should significantly improve the ability of scientists to study early human development.
"Such human embryo-like structures have a lot of potential to open what we call the so-called black box of human development," Fu says.
He's referring to the first few weeks after a sperm fertilizes an egg, when the embryo is inside a woman's body and hard to study. A long-standing guideline bars scientists from conducting research on embryos in their labs beyond 14 days of development for ethical reasons.
Fu says the ability to produce large numbers of embryoids, which are not subject to the 14-day guideline, will hopefully provide scientists with new insights into important health issues, including how to prevent birth defects and miscarriages. In addition, researchers could use the embryoids to screen drugs, to help determine whether the medications are safe for pregnant women to take.
"Such research can lead to a lot of good," Fu says.
Other scientists agree.
"It's a major advance in the knowledge of early human development," says Ali Brivanlou, an embryologist at the Rockefeller University in New York. "We're opening up windows to aspects of development that we have never seen before. This knowledge is really the Holy Grail of human embryology."
Other scientists and bioethicists agree. But they also caution that Fu's research raises sensitive issues.
"This team needs to be very careful not to model all aspects of the developing human embryo, so that they can avoid the concern that this embryo model could one day become a baby if you put it in the womb," says Insoo Hyun, a bioethicist at Case Western Reserve University and Harvard Medical School.
Because of such concerns, Fu says he purposefully made embryoids that are not complete models of full human embryos. They only "resemble a portion of the human embryo — the core of the early human embryo," Fu says. They are missing key structures, such as the early stages of the placenta and "yolk sac," which provide nourishment to embryos.
"I understand that there may be people sensitive when you see that you can massively produce organized embryonic structures. People will be concerned. I understand that. I guess we are pushing the boundary," Fu says.
"But I want to make 100% clear that we have no intention of trying to generate a synthetic structure [that] looks like a complete human embryo," Fu says. "We have zero intention to do that."
Others praised Fu's approach, saying going further would be highly problematic.
"That would be sort of a very early sort of Frankenstein model, right? Taking different parts and stitching them together in order to try to create an organism," says Daniel Sulmasy, a bioethicist at Georgetown University.
"If somebody tried to do it and it were even at the earliest stages of embryonic development, and they tried to then let it develop further, that would be a problem," Sulmasy says.
The device Fu created is a thin silicone square. The plate contains four wells around a narrow channel. The scientists place stem cells — either human embryonic stem cells or induced pluripotent stem cells, which can be made from adult cells — into the device. Next, the researchers add to adjoining wells chemicals that stimulate the cells to grow key structures of human embryos.
Each device can produce about a dozen embryoids in just a few days, Fu says, and that enables the scientists to produce hundreds of the structures by using many of the devices simultaneously.
The rapid advances in embryoid creation have prompted the International Society for Stem Cell Research to launch a review of its guidelines.
"If these embryo models end up being complete and are built to have all the components of natural embryos, they should be subject to the same 14-day rule that limits research with natural human embryos," Hyun says. "That's one more reason to avoid modeling the whole thing at once."
MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:
Scientists have found a way to produce large numbers of living entities that resemble very early human embryos. The step is being hailed as a big advance in the study of human development. It also raises questions about where to draw the line in manufacturing synthetic human life. NPR health correspondent Rob Stein has more.
ROB STEIN, BYLINE: Imagine lab dishes churning out microscopic clumps of human cells, balls of cells that look a lot like very early human embryos. That's what Jianping Fu is doing at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor.
JIANPING FU: The embryonic-like structures we're generating in the lab, they are very similar to - they resemble a portion of the human embryo, the core of the early human embryo.
STEIN: They're made out of human stem cells. Fu isn't the first scientists to start coaxing stem cells into becoming embryoids, as some scientists call them. But Fu figured out how to make lots of them really fast.
FU: So this new system allow us to achieve a superior efficiency to generate this human embryo-like structures. Therefore, it's an exciting new milestone for this emerging field.
STEIN: Fu says he can generate hundreds of embryos in just a few days. But why? Why would anyone want to make lots of living things that look a lot like human embryos?
FU: So such human embryo-like structures have a lot of potential to open what we call the so-called black box of human development.
STEIN: That's the first few weeks after a sperm fertilizes an egg, when the embryo is hidden inside a woman's body. And scientists aren't allowed to study them in their labs for ethical reasons.
FU: During this period, many miscarriages can happen. And serious birth defects can form.
STEIN: So Fu hopes his embryoids will help scientists find new ways to prevent those problems by studying the earliest stages of embryonic development and do other things, like use these embryoids to test drugs to make sure they're safe for pregnant women to take.
FU: So such research can lead to a lot of good.
STEIN: Other scientists agree.
ALI BRIVANLOU: It's a major advance in the knowledge of human - early human development.
STEIN: Ali Brivanlou is an embryologist at the Rockefeller University in New York.
BRIVANLOU: And we're opening up windows to an aspect of development that we have never seen before. This knowledge is really the holy grail of human embryology.
STEIN: But this sort of thing is tricky. Fu's walking a really thin line here. Insoo Hyun is a bioethicist at Case Western Reserve University. He says Fu has done the right thing by making sure his synthetic embryos aren't getting too close to actual human embryos.
INSOO HYUN: The scene needs to be very careful not to model all aspects of the developing human embryo so that they can avoid the concern that this embryo model could one day become a baby if you put it in the womb.
STEIN: Because that would set off all kinds of alarm bells about mass producing human life and experimenting on human embryos. Fu says he gets it.
FU: I understand that there may be people sensitive. When you see that we can massively produce organized embryonic structures, people will be concerned. I understand that. Yeah, I guess we are pushing the boundary.
But I want to make 100% clear that we have no intention trying to generate a synthetic structure look like a complete human embryo. So we have zero intention to do that.
STEIN: But if someone took this technology and did try to go further, Daniel Sulmasy, a Georgetown University bioethicist, says that possibility conjures up some disturbing scenarios.
DANIEL SULMASY: That would be sort of like a very early sort of Frankenstein model - right? - taking different parts and stitching them together in order to try to create an organism. If somebody tried to do it, and it were even at the earliest stages of embryonic development and they tried to then let it develop further, that would be a problem.
STEIN: So the International Society for Stem Cell Research is planning to revise its guidelines for how far scientists should be allowed to go in creating human embryo models from human stem cells.
Rob Stein, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF JONATHAN FITOUSSI AND CLEMENS HOURRIERE'S "LABYRINTHS") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.